I have led paddling trips for many years but it wasn’t until about five years ago that I really started pushing the envelope. That is, going where relatively most fear to tread. Or, it’s just too much trouble.
At any rate, I’m on the verge of such a trip, kayaking through a chain of islands on northern Lake Huron. I’ve been planning it for many months but, as the launch draws near, find myself checking and cross-checking details and beating back the creeping apprehension. The Great Lakes eat titanic ore ships for breakfast. This is no bunny trip.
I’m reading a novel and came across a reference to Magellan. Suddenly, I’m resonating with the mariners of old, sailing off into that great and perilous unknown.
Okay, that may be stretching the comparison. Or is it? Let’s see.
Ships: The fabled explorers sailed wooden ships that were probably smaller than you imagine. We paddle state-of-the-art kayaks.
Advantage: Me. While the kayaks are smaller, they are less subject to the stress and damage of wind and wave.
Navigation: The ancient explorers used compasses, sextants and charts of dubious accuracy (or had none at all). We have good maps and a GPS.
Advantage: Me. Ever try to use a sextant on a rolling sea? Not easy by a long shot. On the other hand, GPS programs aren’t always the best and let’s not even bring up operator error. Nonetheless, I’ll take the edge here.
Information: Magellan and his kin had spotty reports from their antecedents and superstitious lore. I have guide books, trip reports posted on the web and the advice of kayakers through the internet.
Advantage: Magellan. At least the promulgators of legend fabricated stuff that made sense. I’ve sifted through about twenty thousand words of dubious, contradictory, and nebulous input wondering who had firsthand knowledge and who just wanted to be seen as an oracle. I have found everything from references to “relatively calm water” to “waves of 3-4 meters are not unusual.”
Crew: Who could the ancient explorers recruit to risk life and limb in a possibly futile or fatal venture? Those with nothing to lose or who had reason to want to get beyond the reach of the law. I know my kayaking comrades and their skills.
Advantage: Magellan. Like I said, I know the capacity of my paddlers. They follow direction like deaf cats and are almost as intelligent. (Yes, I do anticipate they’re reading this, at least the smaller words.) Their consumption of grog will triple that of their forebearers and you won’t want to find yourself downwind of them.
Native population: The explorers encountered savages, not always welcoming of intruders. We will interface with local officials, outfitters and Canadians who benefit from our patronage.
Advantage: Magellan. Give me a hungry cannibal over an irritable ranger who thinks all kayakers underestimate his backyard any day of the week. Outfitters make their living leading tours and aren’t real warm to the self-guided. I was in Canada last month and it took an average of about four seconds into a conversation before one of the good citizens would bring up how the U.S. screwed up the world economy.
I’m willing to call it a draw. The biggest difference is that many wrote about Magellan’s adventure and no one will write about mine. Hopefully.